PDA

View Full Version : Unearned runs scored correctly.



RAW
05-31-2007, 05:19 PM
Ver. 10.24. Me and others have pointed out the problem (bug) of unearned runs being incorrectly being recorded as earned when an error occurs that would have been the 3rd out of the inning.
Just wanted to point out that in a recent game, with two outs and error was committed, the next batter drove in two runs and they were correctly credited as unearned. So, apparently, in this case, that bug has been corrected. Thanks Clay.

RAW
05-31-2007, 05:28 PM
Going back to look as some bugs about earned/unearned runs. Amazinz's post shows the bug exist when a run scores on an error after two were out. Maybe that bug still exists and just the one I listed, runs scoring on a hit after an error committed with two outs, has been corrected. Any thoughts?

ohms_law
06-01-2007, 04:48 AM
Maybe that bug still exists and just the one I listed, runs scoring on a hit after an error committed with two outs, has been corrected.
Probably. Just keep track of it (you're good at it...) and keep us updated.
:)

RAW
06-01-2007, 02:43 PM
Ver. 10.24. Here's another example of incorrect earned runs recorded
Top of the Fourth (Yankees) Score
Outs Count Pitch (MPH) Willard Nixon on the mound for the Red Sox. Runners NYY BOS
0 3-2 Fastball (91) Mickey Mantle flied out to center field. 0 6
1 3-1 Curve (75) Wally Post walked. 0 6
1 3-0 Fastball (88) Elston Howard singled to left field. 0 6
1 0-1 Fastball (91) Gil McDougald popped up to the shortstop. 0 6
2 2-1 Curve (75) Roy McMillan singled to center field. 0 6
Johnny Blanchard pinch hit for Mike Garcia.
2 2-1 Fastball (87) Johnny Blanchard singled through the right side, scoring a run. 1 6
2 0-1 Change (77) Hank Thompson reached first on a fielding error by the third baseman - a run scored. 2 6
2 3-0 Fastball (87) Norm Siebern singled to center for two RBIs. 4 6
2 3-2 Curve (76) Bill Skowron struck out. 4 6
4 runs, 4 hits, 1 error, and 2 left on base. 4 6

After Thompson reached on an error (that would be the 3rd out of the inning) a run scored (which should be unearned), two other runs (both unearned) scored on Siebern's hit. Line score shows, however, two earned runs and two unearned runs. I suppose that the run scoring on the Thompson AB is counted as earned (incorrect).

RAW
06-01-2007, 04:16 PM
Here's another:
Frank Sullivan on the mound for the Red Sox. Runners KCA BOS
Don Plarski singled back through the middle. 0 0
Don Plarski stole second. 0 0
Danny O'Connell flied out to left field. 0 0
Bill Stewart reached first on a fielding error by the center fielder - a run scored. 1 0
Kent Hadley popped up to short. 1 0
Mel Clark lined out to third. 1 0
1 run, 1 hit, 1 error, and 1 left on base. 1 0
Run was scored as earned, but should be unearned.

JustinM
06-01-2007, 07:00 PM
Yup. That type of run always shows up as earned in BM08.